Jay wrote on 01/26/09 at 21:50:49:Looks great! Love what you did with the seat. Now the all important question, is it comfortable? I'd love to do something like that with mine, especially if it would increase comfort. Thanks.
I love it. I always thought I needed lots of cushion to ride comfortably. I unexpectedly found out otherwise. A bit of history here to help explain- I was doing some extensive mods last summer on my M50 seat. It was slow going but it was summer so i wanted to ride. I rode for about a month on just the plastic seat pan. I discovered that I liked it better than with all of the soft cushion. So I ended up doing this mod to my M50 seat and loved it. The longest I rode on the modded M50 seat it in a day was about 7 hours.
Then I bought this '06 S40 new last summer. After the 30 minute ride home my butt hurt so bad. Parts of my legs and butt were numb in areas I've never been numb before. Getting back on the M50 the next day was like pure luxury compared to the stock S40 seat. Now, I ride the S40 about 30 minutes to work and back with no problem.
I'm 6 foot and weigh 240. I used to think more padding was the answer. For me, thin, dense padding plus a shape that "holds" me works best. There is more contact area now for my butt. It feels a lot like sitting in a saddle. Saddles are hard and have no cushion but people can sit in a saddle for hours without a problem. I noticed that most people that I knew that rode horses can sit in a saddle for much longer periods of time than most people that I knew that rode motorcycles. To me it didn't seem to make a lot of sense. That's when I realized that a good seat shape with minimal padding is more comfortable than a not-so-good shaped seat and lots of padding.
If you happen across a an used seat pan or if you ever take yours apart, try laying a thin piece of padding on it and go for a ride. You might like it too.