I'm a female rider with fairly wide hands for a gal (they measure just over 7.5" around the hand at the knuckles), but SHORT fingers.  A couple of glove sizing charts say that for my hands (women's large), my 2nd finger should be about 3.7" long. NOPE!  It's just barely over 3" long.  I have tried several different brands of gloves and have over 1/2" of excess in all the fingers and the thumbs - not wonderful for working the controls.  If anyone can recommend a brand of gloves to try I would really appreciate it. Newbie old rider here.  

Harbor frieght had some nice black leather gloves a few years back.  You might look to see if yours still carries them.

If you find gloves that fit your hands to be difficult to find I would look for a leather store and ask about a custom made pair as ideal, depending on cost.
I have a similar situation as you, with wider hands but shorter fingers.  Usually if the glove fingers fit the hand portion is too tight, or if the hand portion fits the finger portion is too long.  I have to look a good bit to find pair that fits well.
It is easier for me to find one in the working glove section at Lowe’s, Home Depot, Tractor Supply or Harbor Freight.  Gloves from motorcycle shops don’t fit as well.  Oh, I do have a couple of pair from Under Armor and they fit very well.  I really like those.  I always buy them at one of their Clearance Stores.
Of course, you’ve got to be able to try them on to know for sure.  For me, gloves, hats and shoes are the same, I have to try them on to know they fit.  Ordering on line does not work for me; too many problems not fitting.


.... I did get a really nice pair of dear skin gloves from a vender at the state fair for $25 a couple years ago.  There were no sizes stated, you just tried them on until you found a pair that fit...and these are a perfect for for me.  😎

Success!  Took Justin's suggestion & went to Tractor Supply first.  That got me a wonderful pair of deerskin gloves with short enough fingers.  Went to our local Honda dealership, no luck.  Went to our local HD dealership, which we frequent since hubby rides a Hog, and found an awesome pair of lined leather gloves that fit me very well.  So, now to get past the rainy/snowy/cold days we've been having.

Yup, deerskin, really soft & supple, $19.99 + tax.