The Cincinnati area has a really large Craigslist Market. If you are willing to drive 1-2 hour to find the perfect bike, then Dayton, OH - Louisville, KY - Lexington, KY are also markets. If you are willing to drive 2-3 hours then Columbus, OH - and Indianapolis, IN are also markets.
And don't forget to try typing in alternate searches, as sometimes the folks aren't good at picking a heading that works in the search. The bikes disappear off the front page in a matter of hours - so you have to find the bike of your dreams by typing in the search. For the Savage you need to go into the Motorcycle section and try: LS650, S40, Savage, Suzuki 650.
If you are looking for a particular bike model, you can find a really good buy if you are patient and have the cash to go buy when you find the bargain. An even better buy often comes along if you can buy the bikes that just got abandoned in the garage and need the fuel system cleaned.....a lot of bikes just get put away with fuel in them and the owners don't want to pay to get the new battery and the fuel tank/carb cleaned. (On the Savage....I learned that even on a low 3,800 mile bike it may need a cam and rocker repair from using the owner using the wrong oil).
Bikes like this $ 800 one could be a very good buy......there are several listed for $ 1,000 more that don't look this nice. I would certainly jump start the thing and ride it to make sure it runs and rides OK.
https://cincinnati.craigslist.org/mcy/5272625584.html