Jon wrote on 05/23/12 at 23:24:26:... but I'm not planning on every really going fast...
Oh, you say that NOW!!!
I've been building a RYCA-like Savage with a friend of mine all winter and it's only half done. (See the link to my build thread in my signature below). I've put a lot of heart, a good bit of money and way too much time into this already, and for all I know it may suck for me if I ever get it done; and I've been riding motorcycles almost continuously for 25 years.
Definitely get something used and cheap to start out with; but not too used or too cheap. You want something you can ride and rely on without having to be too fussy with. If you want a UJM standard style ride, that's a great way to start out on the street. The upright riding position really helps give you stability and confidence on the road, and it's the most functional riding position. The stock Savage isn't too crazy cruiser-y, so if you do get one, just ride the thing for a while; a whole summer, before you start thinking about chopping it all up.
RYCA bikes and other cafe bikes look wicked cool in pictures, but they are often more difficult and tempermental to ride, as well as wicked uncomfortable. Every bike is different for every rider, and I can't tell you how many bikes I've bought over the years that I thought were super cool, only to find that I hated riding them or hated owning them.
My other bike is a '92 750 Nighthawk. It's about as exciting to look at as a door knob, but it's been one of the best riding, most comfortable, and most reliable bikes I've ever owned. Paid $1500 for it in perfect running condition, and haven't had to modify a thing. (I have done some stuff for fun, but haven't HAD to) It's been awesome.
Don't be fooled by a sexy package; the only way you'll really know what kind of bike you want to ride is to go out and ride a bunch of bikes.
Cheers!!