Personally, I love mine, but then it's my first bike, so I'm kinda biased.  At your size, I would imagine it should be comfy too; at 5'11" and literally twice your mass, I need some highway pegs soon, to let me stretch out a little.
I'd go with it, especially if it's the color scheme I'm thinking of, with the gray on the gas tank too.  And the price is under what I paid for my '08, I'm jealous!

You have to make the money decision, but as far as the bike is concerned you won't find a better all around machine on the road.  Like any machine, it has a few little quirks but they are easily corrected.  
I have ridden bikes since '66 and have found that bike singles make the best multi-purpose machine on the road.  They are easy to ride, easy and inexpensive to fix, and are just plain fun.

That sounds like a good deal to me.  There are also several 1-2 year old bikes S40s out there with low miles for less but it can be tough for someone to come up with $2500-$2800 whereas buying new gives you payment options.  Mine in an '06 that I bought new last summer.  Mine was advertised for $4300 out the door.  So I guess it was probably around $3800-$3900 before TTL.  As far as fit, I'm 6' and weigh 250.  With just about every bike I've had, I've done something to either the bars, seat, risers and such regardless of how well the bike fit when I first bought it.  Some want a bike that they need to do nothing to and that's fine.  I accepted long ago that I'm eventually going to mod those so it's not a biggie for me.  Doing mods to my seat, risers, bars and the addition of forward controls has made my bike the most favorite riding position of I think about any bike I have had, modded or not.  The bike is great for smaller framed people but has amazing potential to be adaptable to larger people as well.  Plus, I have a lot more fun modding a bike that cost what it does compared to one that costs say $8K or more.  Parts costs less as well.

That's a real deal and if you never make the commitment you'll never own the bike. If you decided to move on afterwards you won't be loosing much if any money on a re-sell.

Just do it, come on do it. Do it, just do it, come on do it. Jussssttttt dooooo iiiiiiiiit!!

That's a steal! Just saw a black one for MSRP last weekend at the stealership, they were no where near 1000 off!!!

Take it and run... er ride  

Tell them to waive the delivery/dealership costs and you'd be more interested...

Those are some crazy charges! PA registration is $36. Our sales tax (@ 6%) was only $240, and that was for $4,000 (which is what I paid for my leftover 07 in 2008).

Certainly not worth $6,000 out the door. (To give you an idea... My $4,000 bike cost me $4,700 after taxes, title and tags, and the delivery cost - There's no way it should be 3x that amount)