Dude,
If you can afford both bikes,
KEEP THE SAVAGE! I also bougth a V* 1100 classic. I love it and have put 29k miles on it, but I am so glad I kept my savage!
First of all, you always need one more bike than you have.
2) It makes a great budy bike.
3) A second bike is for chopping.
4) It's now okay to drop and abuse.
5) When the starter clutch on the V* breaks, you will still have a bike to ride!
The place I bought my V* from was going to give me $4k for the little guy, but I thought about it... I love that darn bike just way too much!
6) Got kids? They can ride it, a classic by then, when they are old enough!
7) some times you just won't want to ride a 600 lb pig. You can ride the ligth as a feather savage instead! Mine is under 300 lbs! and can easily keep up and often outrun my non-stock V* man, these bikes make great choppers!
to reiterate:
If you can afford both bikes,
KEEP THE SAVAGE!