Same as this, a disinformation campaign to excuse the dictatorial acts of the MAGAT minions. The rancher was treated like a corporation, because, functionally, that is what a LLC is. No he wasn't. The multitude of court documents provided prove otherwise. His LLC had nothing to do with the case - you made all that up. Another lie.
Besides, Filing Form 8832 changes an LLC's classification
only for federal income tax purposes. For
all other legal and operational purposes, the entity remains a limited liability company governed by state law according to the IRS, and the State of Wyoming. Even if his LLC was for his private land use, an LLC ONLY applies for tax reasons in regard to Federal jurisdiction specific to the EPA.
Also he
never filed an 8832, so all of the defense using that as an argument doesn't even apply to the Rancher.
Try pointing out the functional differences between corporations and companies. You're lying. I already did twice. The Rancher was not a "Corporation" and his LLC was deemed not pertinient to the EPA case. You keep making up more lies to try to defend your uneducated lie that he was a Corporation. You already admitted you didn't even know the land information showing you assumed he was a large commercial rancher, and not a man that the media called a "Rancher" who really only has a normal land plot.
Lets review:
Needles claims the "Rancher" was a "Corporation" - not true, proven by years of court documents.
Needles claims:
All he had to be to be illegal was to be in the same watershed - not true, proven in the court documents, agreed upon by the EPA. He made that up.
Needles claims "
Ranchers are always corporations" - not true, proven by simple common sense.
Needles claims "
And YOU know d@mned well that the "C" stands for "Corporation" - not true. Proven by historical records, including thousands of clerk corrections correcting "Corporation" to "Company".
Needles claims "
originally CALLED "Limited Liability Corporation" - not true. Proven by historical records and literally taught as such at Harvard Law School.
Needles claims
What about in the event of a lawsuit? THEN, it's suddenly a corporation, to protect the personal finances of the owners." - not true. As a physician that held a license as a "Corporation" he should know where State law applies.
Needles claims: "
By filling out a Form 8832, an LLC is treated the SAME as a corporation by government, law enforcement, and the IRS, with ALL the protections afforded a corporation." - not true. 8832 only applies to income taxes and specifically states it does not impact "
all other legal and operational purposes"
https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-8832 His only defense, as usual, is to pull the name-calling "
MAGAT!!!" card instead of offering the verifiable references he demands of others (where is his referenced proof that an 8832 applies the way he says?) - an action he will not accept from anyone else.
This further proves my assessment, that while Needles may not initially lie about many things, he will often lie in reaction to things he disapproves of, and then continue to make up more things to defend the initial lie.