Guys, he already has experience running a Rebel on the slab. He knows what he's getting into.
I don't think this guy is looking for the "ideal Interstate bike" is he? He's just looking for something like a Rebel with a little more pep for the highway.
The question he should really ask himself is this: Do I really want something in the league of the Honda Rebel, but with a bigger, fuel sucking engine? If yes, then fine.
I have no experience with alternate gearings. With that said, remember that first gear will become taller and harder to deal with if you gear up. Also, our little thumper has a sweet spot.
Go too low, and despite her long stroke, she'll feel luggy, jerky, and vibratory.
Too high, and it feels inefficient. She likes to rev, but she doesn't
. You have to get her just right.
I understand completely your concern about running around 45 mph with alternate gearings. I've had that same concern: whether she'll be in the sweet spot in that crucial little speed. Ya gotta have a gear for every kind of condition.
You need a gear for pulling out and low speed stuff, a gear for 25 mph town driving, a gear for 35 mph, a gear for 45 mph, one for 55-65, and a top Interstate (Autobahn if you're German
) gear. Unfortunately, our Savage doesn't have 6 well spaced gears.
At best it has 5 weird gears
.
Check
http://www.gearingcommander.com/ for the 5 speed LS650 data. Her peak torque is around 3500 rpm, and, depending on tuning, this practical power curve goes up to around 4500 (or from 3000 to 5000 if you're optimistic and all-inclusive). Now, in the lower gears (or lower loads), as you may know, you wont need to cruise at 3500 in many cases since that's just overkill, but 3000 is a good number for moderate speed low load cruising.
Interpreted: 3500-5000 rpm for highway. 3000-4000 for backroads and towns. First and second gear can handle even lower rpms, however. The website indicates that 25 mph in 2nd is around 3k. This is overkill for lazy town riding, so taller gearing may actually help here. There is a huge jump between 2nd and 3rd gear. @ 25, 2nd is a little too much, and 3rd seems luggy
. 2nd is very relaxed at 20 (indicated), though.
This is a combination of personal experience and studying Gearing Commander
. it also follows the experience of others here. If anyone has any comments, you're welcome.
In addition, I have found that, in my experience, downshifting to 4th gear at highway speeds is not very helpful. It pulls great in top gear around 55+